Search

How can we help?

Icon

UK court rules Home Office’s sponsorship requirement for care workers unlawful

In R (Hartford Care Group Ltd) v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2024] EWHC 3308 (Admin), the King’s Bench Division (Administrative Court) ruled that the Home Office’s requirement for specific contracts with guaranteed hours in Defined Certificate of Sponsorship (DCoS) applications for care workers was unlawful. The court found this requirement to be irrational and in breach of the Tameside duty of inquiry.

Case background

Hartford Care Group Ltd, a prominent care home provider with 19 care homes in the UK, challenged the Home Office’s refusal to grant them 70 Defined Certificate of Sponsorships (DCOS) to recruit overseas migrants for their care homes.

On 09 January 2024 Hartford Care Group Ltd submitted an initial DCoS request of 70. The Home Office have previously granted them 93 DCoS.

On 19 January 2024, as part of the application process, the Home Office requested additional documentation, including copies of current official contracts, to demonstrate the vacancies in question were genuine.

On 24 January 2024 – The Home Office rejected the DCoS request. The Home Office based this on the absence of guaranteed working hours in the submitted contracts.

The care home challenged the refusal through the process of judicial review, arguing the decision was irrational and unlawful.

Key findings

  • The Home Office’s demand for guaranteed-hours contracts was deemed irrational and unjustified.
  • The court reaffirmed that a job vacancy can be genuine even without such contracts.
  • The ruling underscores the need for the Home Office to conduct proper inquiries into industry practices before imposing additional requirements.

The Home Office rejected the DCoS request. The Home Office based this on the absence of guaranteed working hours in the submitted contracts.

Implications for employers

This decision has far-reaching consequences, not just for the care sector but for all industries reliant on overseas talent:

Policy and Compliance: The Home Office must review its approach to sponsorship applications, ensuring that additional requirements beyond published rules and guidance are not imposed arbitrarily.

Recruitment Flexibility: Employers now have greater flexibility in structuring job offers without the rigid requirement of guaranteed-hours contracts.

Legal Precedent: The ruling reinforces that immigration policies must align with legal standards and industry norms. This may lead to further challenges where additional, unpublished requirements are imposed.

Sector Confidence: Businesses can have greater certainty in their sponsorship applications, knowing that decisions must be fair, transparent, and legally sound.

How Clarkslegal can assist

At Clarkslegal, we provide strategic immigration advice to businesses across all sectors, ensuring compliance with evolving sponsorship requirements. Our Business Immigration Team can:

  • Assist with sponsorship licence applications and renewals.
  • Advise on best practices for Defined Certificate of Sponsorship (DCoS) applications.
  • Provide legal support in challenging refusals and judicial reviews.
  • Help employers structure compliant job offers without unnecessary restrictions.

If you have any concerns about how this ruling impacts your recruitment strategy or need tailored advice on sponsorship applications, our immigration team is here to help.

Disclaimer
This information is for guidance purposes only and should not be regarded as a substitute for taking legal advice. Please refer to the full General Notices on our website.

Author profile

Ruth Karimatsenga

Senior Associate

View profile

+44 118 960 4606

About this article

Read, listen and watch our latest insights

Pub
  • 19 August 2025
  • Immigration

Navigating New UK Immigration Rules: The 2025 Changes

In our latest podcast, join Ruth Karimatsenga and Monica Mastropasqua from the immigration team as they guide you through the new 2025 UK Immigration Rules.

art
  • 07 August 2025
  • Immigration

New simplified British Citizenship route for Irish Citizens now in force

From 22 July 2025, eligible Irish citizens who have been resident in the UK for five years can now register as British citizens under a new, simplified route.

art
  • 04 August 2025
  • Immigration

The UK Global Talent Visa: Unlocking Opportunities for the World’s Brightest Minds

The Global Talent visa is a prestigious UK immigration route designed to attract exceptional individuals who have demonstrated – or have the potential to demonstrate – significant achievements in science, research, engineering, arts and culture, or digital technology.

art
  • 23 July 2025
  • Immigration

Home Office Announces Major Changes to Skilled Worker Route

On 1 July 2025, the Home Office released a new Statement of Changes (HC 997), delivering on the first phase of what the government calls a “sweeping reform” to the immigration system, as set out in the May 2025 Immigration White Paper. The changes to the Immigration Rules were enforced on 22 July 2025.

art
  • 03 July 2025
  • Immigration

Major Changes to the Immigration Rules from 1 July 2025: What Employers and Visa Holders Need to Know

We outline the key updates, how they affect employers and visa holders—particularly those on the Skilled Worker and Global Business Mobility (GBM) routes—and how our team can assist you in staying compliant and ahead of policy changes.

art
  • 25 June 2025
  • Immigration

Immigration Changes in Statement HC 836 – what do they mean?

The UK government has released its latest Statement of Changes to the Immigration Rules (HC 836), with shocking implementation dates throughout July 2025.