Search

How can we help?

Icon

Fit note changes: Proving employee sickness  

A change in the law from 1 July 2022 increases opportunities for employees to be signed off work when sick. Nurses, occupational therapists, pharmacists and physiotherapists can now sign statements of fitness for work, also known as a GP fit note. This change has been brought in to ease the burden on GPs.

But what might this mean for employers who suspect that a worker is exaggerating their condition for some reason: perhaps to avoid performance management or disciplinary hearings, or to take advantage of contractual sick pay?

The warning to employers from recent tribunal cases is not to make negative assumptions about an employee’s state of health without proper investigation first. In the case of Singh v Metroline West Ltd, Mr Singh succeeded with his claim for constructive dismissal after Metroline withheld his contractual sick pay.

Mr Singh was signed off sick following an invitation to a disciplinary meeting. Metroline believed that he was trying to avoid the hearing and so put him on SSP instead. There was a clause in Mr Singh’s employment contract that allowed Metroline to withhold company sick pay if, following an investigation, his absence was found not to be genuine.

The mistake Metroline made was failing to carry out that investigation which meant they were in breach of Mr Singh’s contract.

Nurses, occupational therapists, pharmacists and physiotherapists can now sign statements of fitness for work, also known as a GP fit note.

The question for the tribunal was whether Metroline’s breach was so serious that it went to the root of the employment contract entitling Mr Singh to resign?

Metroline tried defending Mr Singh’s constructive dismissal claim by saying that it withheld his contractual sick pay to encourage his participation in the disciplinary process.

This argument was rejected by the Employment Appeal Tribunal (EAT) who decided in favour of Mr Singh. The EAT held that Metroline’s decision to withhold his contractual sick pay caused a substantial reduction in Mr Singh’s earnings and was therefore a fundamental breach of his contract. He claim for claim was constructive dismissal was made out.

Metroline may not have lost this breach of contract claim if they had carried out that investigation into whether Mr Singh’s sickness absence was genuine. That said, making judgements about an employee’s state of health and their fitness to carry out their role also carries risks and complications for the employer, especially where there is a potential disability issue.

That is the subject for a separate legal update on sickness absence and capability procedures. In the meantime, employers should consider taking legal advice before trying to withhold either contractual or statutory sick pay because they suspect the sickness is not genuine. Our team of employment lawyers are on hand to help.

Disclaimer
This information is for guidance purposes only and should not be regarded as a substitute for taking legal advice. Please refer to the full General Notices on our website.

Author profile

About this article

Read, listen and watch our latest insights

art
  • 15 September 2025
  • Immigration

Sharp rise in Sponsor Licence Revocations – What employers need to know

The Home Office has reported a record number of sponsor licence revocations over the past year, as part of its intensified efforts to crack down on abuse of the UK’s immigration system.

art
  • 10 September 2025
  • Commercial Real Estate

Trouble at the Table: The Challenges Facing the UK Hospitality Sector in the run up to Christmas 2025

The UK hospitality sector, long celebrated for its vibrancy and resilience, is facing a perfect storm of economic, operational, and structural challenges in 2025.

art
  • 09 September 2025
  • Commercial Real Estate

Le bail commercial anglais: quelques points essentiels à considérer

Typiquement, les baux commerciaux en Angleterre sont de court terme, d’une durée de 5 ou 10 ans, avec un loyer de marché et des ajustements du loyer périodiques en fonction de l’inflation ou d’autres facteurs. 

art
  • 09 September 2025
  • Corporate and M&A

The Failure to Prevent Fraud Offence – be prepared to avoid criminal liability

The failure to prevent fraud offence is a new corporate offence which has come into force on 1 September 2025.

art
  • 08 September 2025
  • Employment

Can employers still make changes to contracts after the Employment Rights Bill?

The short answer is yes but it will be much more difficult for employers following the introduction of the Employment Rights Bill because their ability to fairly dismiss employees who do not agree contractual changes is being restricted. 

art
  • 05 September 2025
  • Privacy and Data Protection

When Ignoring a DSAR Becomes a Criminal Offence

On 3 September 2025, Mr Jason Blake appeared at Beverley Magistrates Court and was fined for failing to respond to a data subject access request (DSAR).