Search

How can we help?

Icon

Duval Case: Beware the Breach of Covenants

The Supreme Court’s decision in the case of Duval v 11-13 Randolph Crescent Ltd [2020] (Duval) is likely to have wide implications for landlords and tenants alike as it concerns the mutual enforceability of tenant covenants which is a standard provision in most modern leases.

Randolph Crescent is a block of 9 flats all subject to a 125-year lease drafted on the same terms. One of the flat owners (Mrs Winfield) wished to make some quite substantial alterations to her basement flat by removing approximately seven metres width of load bearing wall.  Such alterations were prohibited by the lease which contained an absolute covenant not to “cut, maim or injure or suffer to be cut maimed or injured any roof, wall or ceiling within or enclosing the demised premises”.  Mrs Winfield was aware that the alterations she was proposing would be in breach of this covenant and sought a licence for the works from the landlord (in line with the standard alteration provisions in the lease) and provided expert reports to provide some reassurance to the landlord.  On this basis the Landlord was minded to grant a licence to Mrs Winfield for the alterations.

However, Dr Duval who occupied the flat above Mrs Winfield objected. The leases at Randolph Crescent also contained a covenant that the landlord would enforce the lease covenants at the request of another tenant in the building.  Accordingly, Dr Duval argued that since the landlord had undertaken (via the mutual enforceability covenant) to enforce the covenants of the lease, it could not do the opposite i.e. grant a licence for something which was a breach of an absolute covenant, because to do so would render the mutual enforceability covenant ineffective.

The Supreme Court agreed with Dr Duval and as a result of this decision a landlord cannot grant a licence which allows something which would otherwise be a breach of covenant.

Landlords need to be careful not to licence something that is prohibited under the lease

Where there is a block of flats it stands to reason that what one tenant might do to their flat could affect the quiet enjoyment or even property value of the adjoining owners.  Accordingly, landlords need to be careful not to licence something that is prohibited under the lease.  Landlord’s may also want to consider the use and precise wording of absolute prohibitions.  If for example the covenant was drafted so that it was qualified, i.e. such works would require consent, then arguably the landlord would not have been in breach of covenant by providing consent and granting a licence to Mrs Winfield.

About this article

Disclaimer
This information is for guidance purposes only and should not be regarded as a substitute for taking legal advice. Please refer to the full General Notices on our website.

About this article

Read, listen and watch our latest insights

Pub
  • 07 February 2025
  • Corporate and M&A

Talk & Golf : Thinking of Exiting your Business?

Join Stuart Mullins, Partner at Clarkslegal, and Nicky Goringe Larkin, Managing Director at Succession Planning, for a morning breakfast talk on preparing your business for exit, followed by a round of golf at the Eyston Course at Caversham Golf Club.

art
  • 06 February 2025
  • Privacy and Data Protection

Cookies and Consent: the ICO’s Cookie Review

In the digital age, cookies play a crucial role in how websites operate and interact with users.

art
  • 05 February 2025
  • Corporate and M&A

Growing Pains for Businesses

This thought piece considers some of the key issues and pain points facing a business planning to scale up

art
  • 03 February 2025
  • Employment

Indirect discrimination: How mandated office returns could discriminate against working mothers

In this article though, we will focus on one of the biggest potential hurdles, and the one that is garnering the most media attention and the most criticism. Is a return to work policy discriminatory on grounds of sex?

art
  • 24 January 2025
  • Privacy and Data Protection

UK Data Protection: A look back at 2024 and what to expect in 2025

On 15 January 2025, Louise Keenan and Shauna Jones hosted our webinar “UK Data Protection: what happened in 2024 and what’s in store for 2025.” Our webinar is available for you to watch, but in this article, we will provide a brief summary of what was discussed.

art
  • 22 January 2025
  • Corporate and M&A

Deal Announcement: Clarkslegal’s Corporate team advise founder on exit from Bristol based hospitality business

Clarkslegal is pleased to have advised the exiting shareholder and director of a hospitality business in the South West on the sale of their shareholding and termination of their employment.