Search

How can we help?

Icon

Former civil servant brings constructive dismissal claim

The very public resignation of Sir Philip Rutnam has clearly generated the media coverage he anticipated.

While most of the commentary on this case has tended to focus (and divide) on predictable political lines, it is worth focusing on some of the legal aspects, not least because most articles have been misleading and inaccurate on the law.

In his resignation statement, Sir Philip states that he will be claiming constructive unfair dismissal. The statement seems to have been carefully crafted to avoid running the risk of defaming the Home Secretary, while still making clear that he does not believe her account of events.

Unusually, he also publicly stated that he had been offered a settlement as an alternative to pursuing a claim. It is most likely that any settlement offer was made as part of a ‘protected conversation’ meaning that it will not be admissible as evidence to support an allegation that the employer implicitly admitted liability. Of course, publicly claiming that he turned down a settlement offer would still have a PR value to Sir Philip, in order to rebut allegations that his motivation is financial.

Of course, the PR battle won’t decide the legal outcome of the potential claim, which seems to rest on two allegations:

  • that the Home Secretary undermined him by being involved in a negative briefing campaign against him; and/or
  • that the Home Secretary undermined him by failing to dissociate herself from that briefing campaign.

He will have to persuade an employment tribunal that one or both of these allegations is true, that they amount to a fundamental breach of the employer’s duty of trust and confidence and that this is what caused him to resign.

It is most likely that any settlement offer was made as part of a ‘protected conversation’ meaning that it will not be admissible as evidence to support an allegation that the employer implicitly admitted liability.

The respective parties’ involvement and position on Brexit, the Home Office ‘hostile environment’ policy and the present and previous prime minister will not be part of the tribunal’s consideration.

Overall, it is difficult to see how the Home Office will be able to defend the claim without the Home Secretary being called as a witness, which given the relatively limited financial value of the case, is probably the point. It appears that Sir Philip wants to make the Home Secretary face cross-examination about the allegations he claims to have received, that “her conduct has included shouting and swearing, belittling people, making unreasonable and repeated demands – behaviour that created fear”.

As Sir Phillip’s resignation alludes to his duty to protect the health and well-being of Home Office employees, it is also possible that he is going to claim to be have been dismissed because he was a whistleblower, for which compensation Is unlimited…

For advice on media and reputation management in employment disputes, please contact our employment team.

Disclaimer
This information is for guidance purposes only and should not be regarded as a substitute for taking legal advice. Please refer to the full General Notices on our website.

Author profile

About this article

Read, listen and watch our latest insights

art
  • 20 November 2026
  • Corporate and M&A

Buying or investing in a company: Understanding the implications of the National Security and Investment Act

The National Security and Investment Act 2021 (NSIA) allows the UK Government to scrutinise and intervene in transactions that could harm national security. Buyers and investors should assess its requirements early and allow time for any necessary approval before completion.

art
  • 16 November 2026
  • Corporate and M&A

Shareholders’ Agreements for Shareholders and third-party buyers – SHA Series Part 4 of 5

A shareholders’ agreement is a private contract between the shareholders of a company which govern how the company is run, how shares are transferred and how potential disputes are resolved.

art
  • 13 November 2026
  • Immigration

UK Immigration Reform: The End of the 5-Year Settlement Route and the threat of legal action

The UK Government’s proposed changes to Indefinite Leave to Remain (ILR) have sparked growing concern among migrants, employers, and immigration professionals, with a potential legal challenge now being considered.

Pub
  • 09 November 2026
  • Corporate and M&A

Key Provisions found in a Shareholders’ Agreement – Episode 2

Explore the key provisions found in a shareholders’ agreement, including shareholder rights, share transfers, decision-making powers, dispute resolution and minority protections. Listen to Episode 2 of the Clarkslegal podcast for practical guidance.

art
  • 06 November 2026
  • Employment

New Sexual Harassment Prevention Duty: EHRC Guidance on Taking ‘All Reasonable Steps’

Following the changes brought into force by the Employment Rights Act 2025 on 30 October 2026, the Equality and Human Rights Commission (EHRC) has updated its technical guidance on preventing workplace sexual harassment, incorporating the changes imposed by the strengthened “all reasonable steps” preventative duty.

art
  • 03 November 2026
  • Commercial Real Estate

Ban on upwards-only rent reviews: What can landlords of 1954 Act protected leases do?

The commencement of the English Devolution and Community Empowerment Act (the Act) poses a real threat to the interests of landlords whose business tenants are protected under the Landlord and Tenant Act 1954 (LTA) (as well as those that are outside the LTA).