- 07 May 2010
In Martin and others v Professional Game Match Officials Ltd, an employment tribunal has found that a policy of retiring football assistant referees at age 48 constitutes direct age discrimination that cannot be justified.
Age discrimination is unique amongst other forms of discrimination because direct age discrimination is permitted if it can be justified. Regulation 3 of the Age Regulations provides that treatment which is a proportionate means to achieving a legitimate aim will not fall foul of the general prohibition against less favourable treatment on the grounds of age. It was accepted that the referees` employer, the Professional Game Match Officials Limited (PGMOL), had adopted a discriminatory retirement policy, which meant that the Claimants had been treated less favourably on the grounds of their age than PGMOL would have treated other persons not of that age. The issue before the tribunal was, therefore, whether or not that treatment could be justified.
The tribunal considered that PGMOL, in setting a discriminatory retirement policy, had the legitimate aim of creating of a career route for assistant referees. The tribunal held, however, that the retirement policy could only be a proportionate means of achieving that legitimate aim if it could be shown that there was no less discriminatory way of achieving the creation of a career route. The tribunal identified several alternative ways in which PGMOL could have achieved its aim in a less discriminatory way, finding that the retirement policy was not proportionate and therefore not capable of justification. The Claimants` claims of direct age discrimination succeeded.
The tribunal identified several alternative ways in which PGMOL could have achieved its aim in a less discriminatory way, finding that the retirement policy was not proportionate and therefore not capable of justification.
This information is for guidance purposes only and should not be regarded as a substitute for taking legal advice. Please refer to the full General Notices on our website.
About this article
SubjectRetirement policy for football referees falls foul of the Age Regulations
Published07 May 2010
Read, listen and watch our latest insights
- 22 September 2023
Talking Employment Law: New family friendly rights
In this first podcast in the ‘Talking Employment Law’ series, Lucy Densham Brown and Rebecca Dowle, members of the employment team summarise some of the big new family-friendly Bills that are working their way through parliament.
- 07 September 2023
Birmingham Council Equal Pay Claims – How did it go so wrong?
This week, Birmingham City Council formally declared itself in financial difficulty. It issued a Section 114 Notice which states that it has insufficient resources to meet its expenditures and is unable to agree on any solution which would provide suitable funding.
- 21 August 2023
Ethnicity Pay Reporting: Government response to the consultation
The Government consulted on a mandatory approach to ethnicity pay reporting in 2018. Which sought views on the benefits of gathering, monitoring and publishing ethnicity data; data handling, amongst other key areas.
- 09 August 2023
A Guide for Employers: Hidden Disabilities in the Workplace
As an employer, identifying and supporting those with hidden disabilities may present unique and complicated challenges, and so we have put together this guide for employers to aid in this complex area.
- 04 August 2023
Flexible Working Requests: New law
Flexible working is a common occurrence in workplaces in the UK now, with many employees job-sharing, working from home, working flexible hours and more.