Search

How can we help?

Icon

If it’s work-related – it’s not a private matter!

In the recent case of Garamukanwa v Solent NHS Trust an employer was held not to have breached an employee’s right to a private and family life (under Article 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights) when it reviewed private material belonging to the employee on the basis that the information related to work issues and had a potential impact on work.

The Claimant was a clinical manager for the Solent NHS Trust who had formed a personal relationship with a colleague, Ms Maclean.   Following the breakdown of that relationship, the Claimant believed that Ms Maclean had formed a personal relationship with another colleague, Ms Smith.    Ms Maclean and Ms Smith were then the subject of a vendetta which included the sending of malicious emails and photographs to management and other members of staff from various unrecognised email addresses.

Ms Maclean believed the Claimant was responsible and reported events to the police.  Once the police had concluded their investigations they gave the evidence they had collated to the Trust for use in their internal disciplinary investigation.  This evidence included photographs found on the Claimant’s personal iPhone.  The Claimant was subsequently dismissed for gross misconduct.  He brought a claim for unfair dismissal and asserted that viewing private material seized by the police was a breach of Article 8.  His claims were dismissed by the Employment Tribunal.

Chambers and Partners

The Clarkslegal team are commercial and good to work with. They get what our business needs and tell me what I need to hear.

On appeal, the Employment Appeal Tribunal (agreeing with the Tribunal) said that whilst the issues may have related to personal relationships, the Claimant had brought these into the workplace.  He had sent emails to colleagues at work email addresses and “the publication of those emails had an adverse consequence on other employees for whom the Respondent had a duty of care”. The Claimant could not have had an expectation of privacy and, as such, Article 8 was not engaged.  Further, the material from the police could be viewed as a whole and the employer did not need to separate out (and disregard) private material (e.g. the iPhone photographs).  It was expressly recognised that the police had made no such distinction when handing over the information and had given the Trust permission to use all of the information.

The right to a private and family life is wide ranging and is capable of applying to emails at work, provided the individual concerned has a ‘reasonable expectation’ of privacy.  However, this case is part of an emerging trend demonstrating the difficulties individuals face when attempting to rely on Article 8 in a work context.  Earlier this year we commented on the European case of Barbulescu v Romania which ruled that Article 8 would not be infringed if an employer’s monitoring of emails was reasonable and proportionate. In Barbulescu the Claimant was checking his personal emails during working time.  Interestingly, the question of when the emails were sent did not arise in the present case; it was simply sufficient that there was a work-related connection.

Disclaimer

This information is for guidance purposes only and should not be regarded as a substitute for taking legal advice. Please refer to the full General Notices on our website.

Author profile

Monica Atwal

Managing Partner

View profile

+44 118 960 4605

About this article

Read, listen and watch our latest insights

Pub
  • 19 August 2025
  • Immigration

Navigating New UK Immigration Rules: The 2025 Changes

In our latest podcast, join Ruth Karimatsenga and Monica Mastropasqua from the immigration team as they guide you through the new 2025 UK Immigration Rules.

art
  • 18 August 2025
  • Privacy and Data Protection

Top 10 DUAA Compliance Tips for Employers

To support your preparation, we have outlined 10 practical tips to help employers navigate the new requirements and take full advantage of the DUAA’s reforms.

art
  • 15 August 2025
  • Employment

Employment Rights Bill – Get your tailored action plan now!

The Employment Rights Bill is a major piece of legislation which significantly overhauls worker’s rights.

art
  • 13 August 2025
  • Commercial Real Estate

Proposed Ban of upwards only rent reviews

In an effort to save the high street, the government has proposed to ban upwards only rent reviews in commercial leases, without any consultation with professional bodies. It has caught the commercial property sector completely by surprise.

art
  • 12 August 2025
  • Privacy and Data Protection

From WeTransfer to WhatsApp: How Unapproved Tools and “Shadow IT” Could Threaten UK GDPR Compliance

Businesses and self-employed professionals are in a constant pursuit of efficiency and productivity.  There are, as a result, no end of tools and products available to smooth digital workflows. 

art
  • 07 August 2025
  • Immigration

New simplified British Citizenship route for Irish Citizens now in force

From 22 July 2025, eligible Irish citizens who have been resident in the UK for five years can now register as British citizens under a new, simplified route.