- 14 April 2016
In Nayak v Royal Mail Group, the EAT upheld the tribunal’s decision that an employer’s genuine and reasonable belief that an employee was no longer permitted to work in the UK was sufficient to show that he had been dismissed for some other substantial reason (SOSR).
It is Royal Mail’s policy to conduct employee immigration checks every six months where visa outcomes are pending. Mr Nayak worked under a number of visas throughout his employment at Royal Mail (RM) and, upon expiry of his visa in 2010, applied for a Tier 4 (General) student migrant visa. Whilst this was originally refused, he successfully appealed and his application was passed to the Home Office for consideration and processing.
Mr Nayak’s situation meant that he was subject to RM’s immigration check policy. However, when asked to provide proof of his right to work in the UK on three occasions between August 2012 and February 2013, he failed to cooperate with RM’s requests. Further enquiries were made of him between December 2013 and May 2014 and he was told that the right to work could only last whilst his visa application remained pending. Given that his application had been made more than four years previously, and in the absence of any evidence of his immigration status, RM could not simply assume that it remained pending. Mr Nayak was advised that his failure to provide the requisite evidence may result in his dismissal and, when he did not do so, was dismissed. His appeal was unsuccessful and he brought a claim for unfair dismissal.
The EAT upheld the tribunal’s decision that an employer’s genuine and reasonable belief that an employee was no longer permitted to work in the UK was sufficient to show that he had been dismissed for SOSR.
The claim was dismissed both at first instance (by the tribunal) and on appeal. The EAT upheld the tribunal’s decision that an employer’s genuine and reasonable belief that an employee was no longer permitted to work in the UK was sufficient to show that he had been dismissed for SOSR. There was adequate evidence that RM had attempted to establish Mr Nayak’s immigration status over a number of years and he had continually failed to cooperate in the process.
The case demonstrates that a dismissal for SOSR can be justified by the employer’s genuine and reasonable belief. This is in contrast to a statutory restriction dismissal (which is another potentially fair ground for dismissal) where an employer’s actual knowledge is required.
This information is for guidance purposes only and should not be regarded as a substitute for taking legal advice. Please refer to the full General Notices on our website.
About this article
SubjectEmployer’s reasonable and genuine belief can be sufficient for SOSR dismissal
Published14 April 2016
Read, listen and watch our latest insights
- 22 September 2023
Talking Employment Law: New family friendly rights
In this first podcast in the ‘Talking Employment Law’ series, Lucy Densham Brown and Rebecca Dowle, members of the employment team summarise some of the big new family-friendly Bills that are working their way through parliament.
- 20 September 2023
- Commercial Real Estate
Commercial buyers beware of residential Stamp Duty Land Tax
This article discusses a recent case in which a property buyer calculated the Stamp Duty Land Tax due on the purchase at a lower rate, due to the mixed-use purpose of the property.
- 19 September 2023
- Privacy and Data Protection
Organisations’ use of social media: Data protection
Social media applications (or commonly known as ‘apps’) are being developed all the time and we are constantly being introduced to new social media platforms, some of which take almost no time to gain huge popularity.
- 14 September 2023
Entrepreneurial Dreams: What is the Innovator Founder Visa?
In an era defined by innovation and entrepreneurship, the United Kingdom has made a substantial effort towards fostering its reputation as a global hub for start-ups and innovators. The introduction of the UK’s ‘Innovator Founder’ route has marked a pivotal moment in the country’s immigration policy.
- 11 September 2023
- Corporate and M&A
Changes to the tax treatment of Employee Ownership Trusts
The government published a consultation on 18 July 2023 seeking the public’s views on its proposals to reform the tax treatment of Employee Ownership Trusts and Employee Benefit Trusts. Parties are invited to express their opinions via email via the government website until the consultation closes on 25 September 2023.