Search

How can we help?

Icon

Beneficial contract changes made prior to TUPE transfer were void

It is well established that contract changes made solely (or principally) because of a TUPE transfer will be void. However, case law has, so far, focussed on changes that are detrimental to the employee.  In the recent case of Ferguson and ors v Astrea Asset Management Ltd the EAT had to consider beneficial changes.

The Claimants were four directors of a property management company.  Another company was due to take over management of the properties triggering a TUPE transfer.  Prior to the transfer the Claimants changed their contracts of employment to allow for generous guaranteed bonus and termination payments.  Astrea did not accept the transfer of two Claimants under TUPE and the other two, who they accepted transferred, were dismissed immediately after the transfer for gross misconduct as a result of the contract changes.

The Claimants brought various claims against Astrea including breach of contract for the termination payments and unfair dismissal. The EAT held that the contractual changes were void as they were made solely because of the transfer.  This was the case even though they were beneficial changes.   The two Claimants who had been dismissed were successful in their unfair dismissal claims but one of them had been instrumental in changing the contract terms and, as such, had his compensation reduced by 100% on account of his conduct.

Void changes apply to beneficial changes as well as detrimental ones

This case demonstrates that void changes apply to beneficial changes as well as detrimental ones.  The Tribunal said that even if it was wrong about beneficial changes being void, it would have found the changes void on the basis of ‘abuse’ in any event.

About this article

Disclaimer
This information is for guidance purposes only and should not be regarded as a substitute for taking legal advice. Please refer to the full General Notices on our website.

About this article

Read, listen and watch our latest insights

art
  • 21 May 2025
  • Employment

The Rise of Side Hustles and Polygamous Working

In the evolving world of work, the rise of side hustles and “polygamous working” is reshaping the employment landscape in the UK.

art
  • 21 May 2025
  • Privacy and Data Protection

ICO investigating online platforms and the importance of having a good privacy notice

The ICO has recently reported that it is investigating how social media and video sharing platforms use UK children’s personal information.

Pub
  • 19 May 2025
  • Corporate and M&A

Thinking of exiting your business? Part 2

In the second instalment of our three-part series, join Stuart Mullins from Clarkslegal and Nicky Goringe Larkin from Succession Planning as they discuss the complexities surrounding business financing, accounting practices, and valuation strategies, along with key insights into private equity.

Pub
  • 16 May 2025
  • Employment

London Seminar – Understanding the Employment Rights Bill: Legal changes and what they mean for HR

We are pleased to invite you to an in-person seminar at our London office on Tuesday 24th June, hosted by our Employment Law team. Join Monica Atwal, Managing Partner; Katie Glendinning, Partner; and Amanda Glover, Associate, as they unpack the legal implications of the new Employment Rights Bill and what it means for your organisation.

Pub
  • 16 May 2025
  • Employment

Reading Seminar – Understanding the Employment Rights Bill: Legal changes and what they mean for HR

We are pleased to invite you to an in-person seminar at our Reading office Tuesday 17th June hosted by our Employment Law team. Join Monica Atwal, Managing Partner, Katie Glendinning, Partner and Amanda Glover, Associate, will unpack the legal implications of the new Employment Rights Bill and what it means for your organisation.

art
  • 15 May 2025
  • Immigration

The 2025 Immigration White Paper: A Turning Point in UK Immigration Policy

On 12 May 2025, the UK Government unveiled its White Paper titled “Restoring Control Over the Immigration System”, outlining the most substantial proposed changes to immigration law since the post-Brexit overhaul.