Search

How can we help?

Icon

Collateral Warranties: What to look for?

Collateral warranties are a key feature of the construction industry, and they enable beneficiaries such as funders, tenants or purchasers of a development to have a contractual link with the project team. Whilst it is possible to utilise the third party rights act, this route is limited, as seen in the case of Hurley Palmer Flatt Limited v Barclays Bank plc [2014].

Given the importance of collateral warranties, the focus of this article will be to provide a general overview on some of the clauses and limitations that appear in collateral warranties.

Clauses and their effects?

There are a range of clauses that are typical to collateral warranties, but the key ones highlighted here relate to deleterious materials, professional indemnity insurance, copyright, assignment and step-in rights.

  • Deleterious materials – Such a clause will usually contain an obligation to confirm that no deleterious materials which may be damaging to health or the environment will be specified or used in the project. However, it is limited to the level of skill care and diligence required by the professional appointment or building contract.
  • Professional indemnity insurance – This clause requires professional indemnity insurance, with reference to asbestos and contamination exclusions under the policy, to be maintained for a specific period of time (usually 12 years from practical completion of the project).
  • Copyright licence and use of information – These clauses are commonly included to allow a third-party beneficiary to use design information generated by the project, but only in connection with the project. Copyright should be retained by the warrantor.
  • Assignment – It is common for beneficiaries to be afforded the right to assign the benefit of the collateral warranty to a third party. This right to assign may be limited in number to restrict the number of assignments the beneficiary is entitled to.
  • Step-in rights – These are often included to give the beneficiary (usually a funder) the right to take the place of an employer under the main contract if the employer were ever to commit a serious and un-remedied breach, that would otherwise enable the warrantor to terminate their contract with them. In practical terms, this right is beneficial to both the warrantor and the beneficiary as the project may continue to completion even though the employer has committed the serious breach, and so allowing the project value to be realised.

Given the importance of collateral warranties, the focus of this article will be to provide a general overview on some of the clauses and limitations that appear in collateral warranties.

Limitations for the party granting the collateral warranty

A wide range of limitation and exclusion of liability clauses will be relevant when a collateral warranty is being negotiated. These include:

  • No greater liability – If this clause is included, then it confirms that the warrantor will take on no greater risk under a collateral warranty than under the main contract; meaning that they cannot be made to pay more than they would be liable for under the original contract.
  • Equivalent rights of defence – Such a clause stipulates that all the same rights of defence under the main contract will be available to the warrantor under the collateral warranty, ensuring that the contracts are back-to-back.
  • Limitation to the claim period of a beneficiary – This clause limits the period during which a claim can be made by a beneficiary against the warrantor; this is often 12 years from practical completion.
  • Net contribution – This clause apportions liability between each party liable for the same loss or damage and are used to limit the warrantor’s liability to a fair and reasonable amount.

These limitations all should take into account the parties’ bargaining positions and the nature/value of the project.

Comments

In considering these clauses and limitations, the essence of a collateral warranty is that it is ‘collateral’ to the professional appointment or building contract. In practice, collateral warranties may be harder to enforce if the equivalent provisions in the underlying contract are not the same.

Therefore, collateral warranties are only as good as the underlying contract, and so special attention must be paid to ensuring that they are fully ‘back-to-back’ with the underlying contract.

Disclaimer
This information is for guidance purposes only and should not be regarded as a substitute for taking legal advice. Please refer to the full General Notices on our website.

Author profile

About this article

Read, listen and watch our latest insights

art
  • 06 October 2025
  • Employment

TUPE: What It Is, When It Applies, and What HR Needs to Do About It

If you have ever been through a business sale, outsourcing, or insourcing exercise, chances are someone muttered the word “TUPE”, and maybe everyone suddenly looked nervous!

art
  • 02 October 2025
  • Immigration

UK Expansion Worker Route and the Role of Self-Sponsorship

The UK remains one of the most attractive destinations for global entrepreneurs and businesses seeking to establish a presence in Europe.

Pub
  • 02 October 2025
  • Employment

Reading Seminar: Royal Assent Imminent – the Employment Rights Bill! Legal changes and what they mean for HR and their organisations

We are pleased to invite you to an in-person seminar at our Reading office on Tuesday 18th November. Join Monica Atwal, Katie Glendinning, and Amanda Glover as they discuss the legal implications of the new Employment Rights Bill and its impact on your organisation.

Pub
  • 02 October 2025
  • Employment

London Seminar: Royal Assent Imminent – the Employment Rights Bill! Legal changes and what they mean for HR and their organisations

We are pleased to invite you to an in-person seminar at our London office on Tuesday 25th November. Join Monica Atwal, Katie Glendinning, and Amanda Glover as they discuss the legal implications of the new Employment Rights Bill and its impact on your organisation.

art
  • 01 October 2025

Clarkslegal celebrates continued Top-Tier status in Legal 500

Clarkslegal thanks clients for exceptional feedback in its 2026 Legal 500 rankings. Clarkslegal is proud that Legal 500 has recognised the firm in the following areas: Litigation, Property, Corporate & Commercial, Employment and Immigration.

Pub
  • 01 October 2025
  • Corporate and M&A

Green Gains: Unlocking Net Zero for SMEs

Join us for an inspiring evening dedicated to helping small and medium-sized enterprises take practical steps towards net zero.