Search

How can we help?

Icon

Check your Reservations on Rights of Entry

The recent Court of Appeal case of Rees -v- Windsor-Clive (2020) considered the interpretation of Landlord’s rights of entry reserved by a lease.

It is quite rare for the issue of reserved rights to come before the courts for detailed consideration and the judgment handed down by Lord Justice Lewison will be of great interest to landowners and developers for its common sense, pragmatic approach.

The facts of the case

The landlord in this case owned a large farm in Wales which had been let to a tenant on two farming tenancies granted in 1965 and 1968.  The Landlord obtained outline planning permission for a housing development. In order to comply with certain planning conditions, the landlord needed to gain access to the farm to dig trial pits and boreholes, place surveyor’s reference pins on the land and leave remote bat detectors on the land to monitor the bat population.

The tenancy agreements reserved rights of access to the landlord to gain access to the farm, and one of the tenancies reserved the right for the landlord to gain access to the farm “at all reasonable times for all reasonable purposes”.

First Instance Decision

This case first came before the High Court when the landlord applied for an injunction to stop the tenant interfering with the exercise of his rights of entry. The High Court refused to grant the injunction but held that the landlord was entitled to gain access to the farm to carry out some of the works required by their planning consent.

The tenant appealed against the High Court decision to permit the Landlord to carry out certain activities.

Court of appeal decision

The Court of Appeal dismissed the tenant’s appeal. They determined that if rights of entry had been reserved by a lease for “reasonable purposes”, then those reasonable purposes should be interpreted in the context of the land and all relevant circumstances.

If the right of entry that the Landlord intended to exercise was for a very intrusive purpose, then the court indicated that this might not be a reasonable purpose.

This issue has previously been considered by the Scottish courts in the context of petrol station leases (Possfund Custodial Trustee Limited v Kwik-Fit Properties Limited, Court of Session [2008]), where the court held that it was not envisaged or intended by the parties to the lease that the exercise of the landlords’ right of inspection would cause any material disturbance to the tenants, or would result in any material damage to the premises. However, in the Rees case the Court of Appeal stated that:

“what might be intrusive in that context (a lease of a petrol filling station), might not be intrusive in the case of a 51-acre farm.  It is, as a I said a question of fact and degree”.

The Court of Appeal made clear that they did not support an overly restrictive interpretation of the reservations contained in the lease, and that the court was not required to give a right of entry the narrowest possible interpretation.

Another interesting point to note from this judgement concerns the principle of non-derogation from grant.  The Court of Appeal took the view that a landlord exercising rights in accordance with the terms of a lease would not be derogating from grant, as the rights being exercised formed part of the grant.

At the point of granting a lease, a landlord will often reserve broad rights of access, to encompass a wide range of possible reasons for which they may require access during the term of the lease. The decision in this case should provide comfort to landlords looking to redevelop or repurpose existing buildings, without fear of tenants objecting or seeking to delay the exercise of rights of entry.

A land owner or developer wishing to gain access to a tenant’s demise in order to carry out surveys or site investigations should check the wording of the lease to ensure they have sufficient rights of entry

Final note

It is worth noting that in the Rees case, the tenancy agreement gave the landlord a right of access at all reasonable times and for all reasonable purposes.  While this wording is relatively commonplace, not all leases will contain the same reservations, and some may be more limited, particularly where a tenant has legitimate concerns about site security or sensitive equipment on site.

A land owner or developer wishing to gain access to a tenant’s demise in order to carry out surveys or site investigations should check the wording of the lease to ensure they have sufficient rights of entry, and to ensure they comply with any prior notice requirements contained in the lease.

If you would like any advice on any of the issues raised in this article, please contact our Real Estate Team.

About this article

Disclaimer
This information is for guidance purposes only and should not be regarded as a substitute for taking legal advice. Please refer to the full General Notices on our website.

About this article

Read, listen and watch our latest insights

art
  • 10 April 2024
  • Employment

New Guidance: Confidence to Recruit

The new Government guide in collaboration with the CIPD aims to give employers the confidence to recruit its workforce from a wider range of people including those who may have been overlooked in the past as a problem rather than an asset.

art
  • 03 April 2024
  • Employment

FAQ’s on the new Carer’s Leave Act

Beginning on 6 April 2024, the Carer’s Leave Act comes into force, meaning carers are now entitled to request 1 week’s unpaid leave to care for their dependants.

art
  • 02 April 2024
  • Construction

UK housebuilders investigated over suspected exchanges of anti-competitive information

In 2022 the CMA was called upon by the Secretary of State for the Department for Levelling Up, Housing & Communities to conduct a study into the housebuilding sector and provide recommendations on how the sector can operate as efficiently as possible

art
  • 28 March 2024
  • Corporate and M&A

Legal perspectives on ESG and director duties

In today’s rapidly changing business landscape, the concept of ESG factors has emerged as a guiding framework for companies seeking to thrive in the long term.

art
  • 27 March 2024
  • Commercial Real Estate

5 key considerations when taking on a lease of a pub property

Taking on a pub property can be both exciting and daunting. Here are 5 key considerations that pub tenants should consider when taking on this new venture.

art
  • 26 March 2024
  • Employment

Navigating Neuroinclusion: A Guide for Employers

Over the past few years, we have seen a marked rise in awareness of neurodiversity, as well as campaigns for awareness and inclusion in the workplace for neurodiverse employees.