Search

How can we help?

Icon

Negotiating a settlement

Employers should tread carefully when negotiating settlement deals even where the employee has initiated the discussion as, until an employee signs a valid settlement agreement, the employee can bring a potentially costly claim. 

Settlement agreements inolve careful negotiation and  offers and counter offers to reach an agreeement. A settlement agreement is a legally binding document which settles any claims an employee has against an employer and pays a sum of money in return for settling and leaving employment.

To ensure your organisation interests are protected, it is important to be clear to keep the terms of the agreement confidential.

In the case of Gibbs v Leeds United Football Club, the High Court found that the Claimant, Mr Gibbs, had been constructively dismissed when he resigned in response to a demotion, even though he had been in negotiations over his exit.

Mr Gibbs was the Assistant Manager of Leeds United FC, working under a fixed term contract from April 2013 that expired on 30 June 2016. In June 2014, following the departure of the club’s manager, Mr Gibbs discussed with the club the possibility of him leaving if the next manager brought his own assistant manager, as well as the terms of a potential exit package.

Shortly after this, a new manager and assistant coach were appointed and Mr Gibbs was not provided with work, despite turning up to work as usual. He was later told that he was to work with the under 21s and 18s rather than the first team.

Monica Atwal

Managing Partner

View profile

+44 118 960 4605

To ensure your organisation interests are protected, it is important to be clear to keep the terms of the agreement confidential.

He resigned in response, claiming he had been constructively dismissed. Mr Gibbs pursued his claim in the High Court, presumably because he did not have the necessary 2 years’ service to bring a claim of unfair dismissal and was seeking more than the Employment Tribunal is able to award for breach of contract claims (currently up to £25,000).

The High Court held that Mr Gibbs had been constructively dismissed – the actions of the club had been a repudiatory breach of contract which caused him to resign. The fact that Mr Gibbs had been willing to negotiate a termination package and had initiated this discussion did not prevent his claim for constructive dismissal as he remained willing to fulfil his contractual duties.

This case highlights the need for employers to tread carefully when negotiating settlement deals even where the employee has initiated the discussion as, until an employee signs a valid settlement agreement, the employee can bring a potentially costly claim.  In this case, as Mr Gibbs’ fixed term contract could not be ended earlier by the parties, he was entitled to the pay he would have received had he not been dismissed and was awarded an eye-watering £331,426.

About this article

Disclaimer

This information is for guidance purposes only and should not be regarded as a substitute for taking legal advice. Please refer to the full General Notices on our website.

Monica Atwal

Managing Partner

View profile

+44 118 960 4605

About this article

Read, listen and watch our latest insights

art
  • 07 August 2025
  • Immigration

New simplified British Citizenship route for Irish Citizens now in force

From 22 July 2025, eligible Irish citizens who have been resident in the UK for five years can now register as British citizens under a new, simplified route.

art
  • 06 August 2025
  • Employment

Enhanced redundancy packages explained

It is difficult for employees and employers alike when the time comes to make redundancies across a business. For those impacted, it can be particularly difficult to understand the terms used, and what your entitlements are as an employee.

art
  • 06 August 2025
  • Litigation and dispute resolution

Product liability reform: New Product Regulation and Metrology Act 2025

The law on product safety is set to undergo reform as the new Product Regulation and Metrology Act 2025 was passed in July.

art
  • 04 August 2025
  • Immigration

The UK Global Talent Visa: Unlocking Opportunities for the World’s Brightest Minds

The Global Talent visa is a prestigious UK immigration route designed to attract exceptional individuals who have demonstrated – or have the potential to demonstrate – significant achievements in science, research, engineering, arts and culture, or digital technology.

art
  • 29 July 2025
  • Commercial Real Estate

Right to Renew: The Law Commission’s Statement

Many commercial tenants occupy their premises under tenancies. Part 2 of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1954 (the “Act”) gives these business tenants the right to remain in their premises when their tenancies would have otherwise come to an end, this is known as a “right to renew” or “security of tenure”.

art
  • 29 July 2025
  • Corporate and M&A

Articles of Association v. Shareholders Agreement in England and Wales: Which one works best for you and your company?

The decision of whether to solely rely on a company’s Articles of Association or implement a bespoke Shareholders’ Agreement depends on the specific needs and priorities of the individual shareholders and the company alike.