Search

How can we help?

Icon

The Supreme Court holds that the abuse of migrant domestic workers is not race discrimination

In Taiwo v Olaigbe and Onu v Akwiwu, the Supreme Court has held that although the severe mistreatment of migrant domestic workers was because of their immigration status, this did not amount to race discrimination.

Ms Taiwo and Ms Onu were Nigerian nationals working for two separate Nigerian families in London under “domestic workers in a private household” visas. They were both exploited and treated extremely badly by their respective employers and, once they managed to escape, each brought a variety of claims in the Tribunal and were awarded compensation for not receiving the minimum wage and not being allowed rest breaks. However, on appeal, the EAT and Court of Appeal both held that they had not been racially discriminated against.

The claimants appealed to the Supreme Court which had to decide whether their mistreatment because of their vulnerability as migrant workers constituted direct race discrimination. As immigration status does not appear on the list of protected characteristics in the Equality Act, the Court had to decide whether immigration status was so closely linked to nationality that the two could not be separated. Whilst the Court agreed that immigration status is a ‘function’ of nationality, in that British nationals have the right to live and work here but others are subject to immigration control, there are many different kinds of immigration status and, in this case, it was the terms of the claimants’ visas (and their dependence on their employer) which made them particularly vulnerable. Many non-British nationals working in Britain do not share this vulnerability and therefore would not have been treated so badly in the same circumstances. Given that the Tribunals had found that the reason for the employees’ treatment was their immigration status not their nationality, the claim for direct discrimination could not succeed.

Monica Atwal

MANAGING PARTNER

View profile

+44 118 960 4605

Chambers and Partners

The Clarkslegal team are commercial and good to work with. They get what our business needs and tell me what I need to hear.

Whilst the facts of this case are (hopefully) quite unusual, it does highlight the importance for employers of understanding and articulating the reason for an employee’s treatment in a potential direct discrimination claim. When it comes to dealing with employees on UK visas, whilst the finding that immigration status does not necessarily fall within the protected characteristic of race is helpful, employers still need to think carefully about why they might be treating such staff differently or less favourably, as a Tribunal could still find that the difference in treatment is in fact owing to their nationality rather than immigration status.

Employmentbuddy.com 

About this article

Disclaimer

This information is for guidance purposes only and should not be regarded as a substitute for taking legal advice. Please refer to the full General Notices on our website.

Monica Atwal

MANAGING PARTNER

View profile

+44 118 960 4605

About this article

Read, listen and watch our latest insights

art
  • 01 June 2023
  • Employment

Facts employees should know about their personal data

We previously published an article on facts an employer should know about holding personal data, so it is only fair that we also write about the other side of the coin – facts employees should know as individuals whose personal data is held by their employer.

art
  • 01 June 2023
  • Immigration

What is the Immigration Skills Charge (ISC) and how much do you have to pay?

The Immigration Skills Charge (ISC) is a levy on companies who sponsor migrant workers. This levy was imposed on 6 April 2017. The Government states that the charge has been levied to contribute towards addressing the skills gap in the local economy.

art
  • 26 May 2023
  • Employment

Avoiding discrimination in flexible working requests

The right to request flexible working is currently available to employees with at least 26 weeks’ service and is set to be extended further under new Government reforms.

art
  • 25 May 2023
  • Corporate and M&A

Management Buyout – Top 5 things to consider

A management buyout is a financial transaction in which a member of the management team purchases the company from its registered owner. MBO’s usually occur in private companies in an effort to enhance profitability and simplify strategies.

art
  • 25 May 2023
  • Employment

Carer’s Leave Bill set to become law

On 19 May 2023, the Carer’s Leave Bill had its third reading in the House of Lords, and upon receiving Royal Assent, will become law. There is not yet a date for the implementation of this bill, however it is likely that this will happen relatively quickly upon receiving Royal Assent, so is definitely one to keep an eye on.

art
  • 18 May 2023
  • Immigration

Navigating SOC Codes

When it comes to UK immigration, understanding the intricacies of the system is vital. One significant aspect of the process revolves around Standard Occupational Classification (SOC) codes. SOC codes play a crucial role in determining the eligibility for an individual to apply for a work visa, assessing skill levels, and matching individuals to appropriate job roles.