Search

How can we help?

Icon

Lack of knowledge of employee’s protected disclosures did not prevent a finding of automatic unfair dismissal

In the recent case of Royal Mail Group Limited v Jhuti, the Employment Appeal Tribunal decided that an employee had been automatically unfairly dismissed even though the manager responsible for the decision had been unaware of her protected disclosures.

After only 4 weeks of employment, Ms Jhuti became suspicious that her colleague had breached Royal Mail’s policies and Ofcom requirements.  She informed the team leader and was advised to admit she had been mistaken and to retract her allegations.  Fearing for her job, she did just that.  She was subsequently given an “ever changing unattainable list of requirements” and was put on a performance management plan.  Ms Jhuti complained to HR that she was being harassed and bullied as a result of her disclosures, but this was not dealt with properly.

A different manager was then appointed to review Ms Jhuti’s performance.  She was not given copies of Ms Jhuti’s emails containing the disclosures but became aware that she had been upset about something.  When asked, the team leader told the manager that Ms Jhuti had complained about improper conduct at Royal Mail but had subsequently retracted her allegations.  The manager did not meet with Ms Jhuti (as she was unwell) and took the information from the team leader at face value.  Ms Jhuti was dismissed for poor performance.

The Employment Tribunal found that Ms Jhuti had made protected disclosures and had been subjected to detriments.  However, it decided that she had not been automatically unfairly dismissed because the decision was not based on someone else’s motivation.  The manager had been unaware of Ms Jhuti’s disclosures and genuinely believed she was a poor performer.  On appeal however, the EAT took a different approach, noting that the team leader had intentionally misled the manager about Ms Jhuti’s disclosures. The EAT considered it was imperative that the team leader’s reason and motivation should be taken into account and concluded that it was inevitable that Royal Mail would be found to have dismissed Ms Jhuti because she had made protected disclosures.

Monica Atwal

Managing Partner

View profile

+44 118 960 4605

Chambers and Partners

The Clarkslegal team are commercial and good to work with. They get what our business needs and tell me what I need to hear.

It remains to be seen whether an employer would be held liable if the manipulation is done by someone in a non-managerial position who is not responsible for the employee.

For further information or support with unfair dismissal or protected disclosures, please contact our specialist employment lawyers on employment@clarkslegal.com

Employmentbuddy.com 

About this article

Disclaimer

This information is for guidance purposes only and should not be regarded as a substitute for taking legal advice. Please refer to the full General Notices on our website.

Monica Atwal

Managing Partner

View profile

+44 118 960 4605

About this article

Read, listen and watch our latest insights

art
  • 12 June 2024
  • Privacy and Data Protection

UK data protection: Important basics

Sometimes, data protection can seem like unhelpful red tape. At other times, it is critical to cultivating a trustworthy reputation.

art
  • 11 June 2024
  • Immigration

UK Immigration Roundup – May to June 2024

As the UK approaches the upcoming general election, immigration remains a focal issue in political discussions. The Conservative party’s recent proposal to cap visas for skilled migrant workers has alarmed various industries who are concerned that a limit to migration could harm vital sectors of the UK economy.

Pub
  • 06 June 2024
  • Employment

Talking Employment Law: What does the new Worker Protection Act 2023 mean for employers?

In this podcast, Lucy Densham Brown and Shauna Jones, members of the employment team, will review the new Worker Protection Act 2023 and provide some guidance on how employers should review their policies in preparation for October.

art
  • 03 June 2024
  • Commercial Real Estate

Sustainability and commercial property: green leases  

Climate change is considered by many the biggest threat we are facing today. With the UK said to have one of the oldest housing/building stocks, the focus on a building’s environmental performance and sustainability has never been more critical.

art
  • 03 June 2024
  • Employment

Using AI technologies in recruitment: is it fair and transparent?

In a rapidly evolving digital landscape, where artificial intelligence (AI) plays an increasingly pivotal role in HR and recruitment processes, ensuring responsible and ethical implementation is paramount.

Pub
  • 03 June 2024
  • Employment

Navigating the Labour Party’s New Deal for Working People: Legal implications and opportunities

Join Monica Atwal and Amanda Glover, for this in-person seminar on ‘Navigating the Labour Party’s New Deal for Working People: Legal Implications and Opportunities’ at our Reading office on Thursday, 20th June.