Search

How can we help?

Icon

If it’s work-related – it’s not a private matter!

In the recent case of Garamukanwa v Solent NHS Trust an employer was held not to have breached an employee’s right to a private and family life (under Article 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights) when it reviewed private material belonging to the employee on the basis that the information related to work issues and had a potential impact on work.

The Claimant was a clinical manager for the Solent NHS Trust who had formed a personal relationship with a colleague, Ms Maclean.   Following the breakdown of that relationship, the Claimant believed that Ms Maclean had formed a personal relationship with another colleague, Ms Smith.    Ms Maclean and Ms Smith were then the subject of a vendetta which included the sending of malicious emails and photographs to management and other members of staff from various unrecognised email addresses.

Ms Maclean believed the Claimant was responsible and reported events to the police.  Once the police had concluded their investigations they gave the evidence they had collated to the Trust for use in their internal disciplinary investigation.  This evidence included photographs found on the Claimant’s personal iPhone.  The Claimant was subsequently dismissed for gross misconduct.  He brought a claim for unfair dismissal and asserted that viewing private material seized by the police was a breach of Article 8.  His claims were dismissed by the Employment Tribunal.

Chambers and Partners

The Clarkslegal team are commercial and good to work with. They get what our business needs and tell me what I need to hear.

On appeal, the Employment Appeal Tribunal (agreeing with the Tribunal) said that whilst the issues may have related to personal relationships, the Claimant had brought these into the workplace.  He had sent emails to colleagues at work email addresses and “the publication of those emails had an adverse consequence on other employees for whom the Respondent had a duty of care”. The Claimant could not have had an expectation of privacy and, as such, Article 8 was not engaged.  Further, the material from the police could be viewed as a whole and the employer did not need to separate out (and disregard) private material (e.g. the iPhone photographs).  It was expressly recognised that the police had made no such distinction when handing over the information and had given the Trust permission to use all of the information.

The right to a private and family life is wide ranging and is capable of applying to emails at work, provided the individual concerned has a ‘reasonable expectation’ of privacy.  However, this case is part of an emerging trend demonstrating the difficulties individuals face when attempting to rely on Article 8 in a work context.  Earlier this year we commented on the European case of Barbulescu v Romania which ruled that Article 8 would not be infringed if an employer’s monitoring of emails was reasonable and proportionate. In Barbulescu the Claimant was checking his personal emails during working time.  Interestingly, the question of when the emails were sent did not arise in the present case; it was simply sufficient that there was a work-related connection.

Disclaimer

This information is for guidance purposes only and should not be regarded as a substitute for taking legal advice. Please refer to the full General Notices on our website.

Author profile

Monica Atwal

Managing Partner

View profile

+44 118 960 4605

About this article

Read, listen and watch our latest insights

art
  • 20 November 2026
  • Corporate and M&A

Buying or investing in a company: Understanding the implications of the National Security and Investment Act

The National Security and Investment Act 2021 (NSIA) allows the UK Government to scrutinise and intervene in transactions that could harm national security. Buyers and investors should assess its requirements early and allow time for any necessary approval before completion.

art
  • 16 November 2026
  • Corporate and M&A

Shareholders’ Agreements for Shareholders and third-party buyers – SHA Series Part 4 of 5

A shareholders’ agreement is a private contract between the shareholders of a company which govern how the company is run, how shares are transferred and how potential disputes are resolved.

art
  • 13 November 2026
  • Immigration

UK Immigration Reform: The End of the 5-Year Settlement Route and the threat of legal action

The UK Government’s proposed changes to Indefinite Leave to Remain (ILR) have sparked growing concern among migrants, employers, and immigration professionals, with a potential legal challenge now being considered.

Pub
  • 09 November 2026
  • Corporate and M&A

Key Provisions found in a Shareholders’ Agreement – Episode 2

Explore the key provisions found in a shareholders’ agreement, including shareholder rights, share transfers, decision-making powers, dispute resolution and minority protections. Listen to Episode 2 of the Clarkslegal podcast for practical guidance.

art
  • 06 November 2026
  • Employment

New Sexual Harassment Prevention Duty: EHRC Guidance on Taking ‘All Reasonable Steps’

Following the changes brought into force by the Employment Rights Act 2025 on 30 October 2026, the Equality and Human Rights Commission (EHRC) has updated its technical guidance on preventing workplace sexual harassment, incorporating the changes imposed by the strengthened “all reasonable steps” preventative duty.

art
  • 03 November 2026
  • Commercial Real Estate

Ban on upwards-only rent reviews: What can landlords of 1954 Act protected leases do?

The commencement of the English Devolution and Community Empowerment Act (the Act) poses a real threat to the interests of landlords whose business tenants are protected under the Landlord and Tenant Act 1954 (LTA) (as well as those that are outside the LTA).