Search

How can we help?

Icon

Employment Tribunal awards former police officer £1.1million compensation for discrimination claim

An Employment Tribunal has awarded a former police officer £1.1 million in compensation for a disability discrimination and constructive dismissal claim in Mrs K Hibbert v The Chief Constable of Thames Valley Police: 3310944/2020. The claim was brought against Mrs Hibbert’s employer who withdrew permission allowing the former officer to run an events business alongside her policing role.

Background to the claim

The Claimant, Mrs Hibbert, worked for the Thames Valley Police (TVP) as a safeguarding sergeant which involved working with young people who were subject to child sexual exploitation and child drug exploitation. Prior to the matter of the claim, Mrs Hibbert had an exemplary 20 years’ service in the force and had never been subject to any complaint.

Mrs Hibbert began experiencing panic attacks and PTSD symptoms in 2018, attributable to the emotionally intense work that was involved in the role. She was advised by an occupational health nurse to have other interests and hobbies outside of work to help cope with the intensity of it and for the benefit of her mental health. Under the Police Regulations 2003, carrying on a secondary business is a type of ‘business interest’ and police officers must apply for permission to do so. Mrs Hibbert, therefore, requested and received permission from TVP to set up a small party and events business which she did alongside her role.

In 2019, Mrs Hibbert was negatively affected after learning that a vulnerable young person that she had been working with had passed away and she was signed off work due to stress. During this time, she continued to work on her events business for therapeutic reasons and to help with her recovery.

Whilst Mrs Hibbert was absent on sick leave, TVP reviewed her business interest permission and found out through Facebook that her business still remained active whilst she was away. TVP came to the decision to remove her permission to carry out a business interest on the basis that it was impacting her return to work, Mrs Hibbert appealed this decision but the removal was upheld.

TVP later started disciplinary proceedings against Mrs Hibbert for alleged gross misconduct for carrying on with her business once permission had been removed, as there had been several occasions where Mrs Hibbert had carried out some activities for the events business knowing that her permission to do so had been withdrawn. Mrs Hibert resigned from her role in January 2020, but the conduct process continued after her resignation. A conduct hearing was held in June 2020 but was dismissed on the basis that TVP failed to follow the Police Regulations 2003 in respect of the business interest appeal procedure. In August 2020, Mrs Hibbert brought a claim against TVP for disability discrimination and constructive dismissal.

Jesse Akiwumi

Solicitor

View profile

+44 118 960 4662

The compensation for future financial losses totalled £602,570

Tribunal’s judgement and award

It was the Tribunal’s view that Mrs Hibbert was still able to work on her events business during her period of leave as it was helpful for her recovery, and the withdrawal of permission was a removal of a significant coping mechanism. The Tribunal held that TVP had failed to make reasonable adjustments and that discrimination had arisen from Mrs Hibbert’s disability in respect of the withdrawal of the permission to conduct a business interest. The claim for constructive discriminatory dismissal succeeded.

Mrs Hibbert was awarded a total sum of £1,168,561 in compensation. When determining the appropriate sum, it was the medical expert’s opinion that Mrs Hibbert was unable to work for the police force any longer, so had lost both her income for the remainder of her working life and her pension entitlement, which was calculated to be £13,375 per year from the age of 60. The compensation for future financial losses totalled £602,570.

The Tribunal also conducted a grossing up exercise to decide what tax would be payable and to make an additional award to reflect this, so that Mrs Hibbert would receive a sum which broadly represented the figure awarded by the Tribunal. This amounted to a substantial further sum of £500,207 being awarded.

The grossing up exercise was necessary in this case as majority of the compensation, most notably the future income losses and pension payments, were taxable. It is unusual for a Tribunal to award such a large sum of compensation but this was due to the specific facts of this case, as Mrs Hibbert was entitled to a highly valuable pension in her public sector role with TVP and the pension payments would have not been subject to much tax if she had received them yearly, however when receiving them all in one payment it would be taxed at much higher rates.

If you would like some guidance regarding a potential disability claim or how to balance the needs of your employees with the needs of the business, please get in touch with our employment team who can provide you with expert advice.

About this article

Disclaimer
This information is for guidance purposes only and should not be regarded as a substitute for taking legal advice. Please refer to the full General Notices on our website.

Jesse Akiwumi

Solicitor

View profile

+44 118 960 4662

About this article

Read, listen and watch our latest insights

Pub
  • 24 March 2025
  • Employment

Talking Employment Law: The Employment Rights Bill – Part 1

In part 1 of the Employment Rights Bill podcast in the ‘Talking Employment Law’ series, Louise Keenan and Lucy White, members of the employment team, will discuss some of the main provisions of the Bill, including unfair dismissal and family rights.

art
  • 21 March 2025
  • Employment

Increase to Tribunal Award Limits Effective from 6 April 2025

As of 6 April 2025, the Employment Rights (Increase of Limits) Order 2025 will increase the compensation limits which apply to various Employment Tribunal awards as well as other statutory payments.

art
  • 07 March 2025
  • Employment

International Women’s Day 2025: A Call to Action for Employers to Champion Gender Equality in the Workplace

As we mark International Women’s Day 2025, it’s essential to reflect on the current state of gender equality in the workplace and the role employers can play in driving change.

art
  • 06 March 2025
  • Employment

Government tables key amendments to the Employment Rights Bill

The Government has proposed a series of significant amendments to the Employment Rights Bill, which will be considered in Parliament.

art
  • 05 March 2025
  • Employment

Are older workers being failed by discrimination laws?

We have seen a lot of disparities between younger and older people, particularly relating to working arrangements and the “digital age”, and the perception of older people during the national response to COVID-19.

art
  • 25 February 2025
  • Employment

Carnival PLC v Hunter – Understanding maternity leave protections during redundancy

In the recent case of Carnival PLC v. Hunter, the Employment Appeal Tribunal (EAT) explained the position regarding offering suitable alternative roles for employees on maternity leave who face redundancy.