Search

How can we help?

Icon

Claims for payment – when is it too late?

One of the first things you learn as a law student is that the standard limitation period for claims in contract is six years in the UK. But when do the six years start running?

That is the question the court had to answer in Hirst v Dunbar. The construction works were completed in December 2012, payment demanded in March 2014 and legal proceedings issued in August 2019.  Accordingly, limitation would be a problem if time started running when the work was completed but not if the six years ran from the date of the demand.

In the event, the claim failed because there was no contract in place. However, the court went on to consider the limitation point and give some helpful guidance on an issue that had not previously been ruled upon.

Mr Hirst relied on the Scheme for Construction Contracts, which set out a default payment mechanism when payment isn’t expressly dealt with in a contract. Paragraph 6 of the Scheme says that the payment of the contract price is 30 days after the completion of the works or the making of a claim, whichever is later.

In turn, Mr Hirst said that his right to be paid arose under paragraph 9 of the Scheme, which was when a payment notice should have been issued five days after the due date for payment.

The court disagreed. The starting point is that the right to be paid arose when the works were completed and clear wording is required to displace this presumption.  The Scheme didn’t amount to such wording.  The situation would be different if the contract required a further condition to be satisfied before the entitlement to payment was satisfied, such as the issue of a certificate by a party appointed to administer the contract.

One of the first things you learn as a law student is that the standard limitation period for claims in contract is six years in the UK. But when do the six years start running?
.

The Scheme didn’t have this effect, particularly as the payment mechanism was only engaged following a claim for payment. It would be unfair to let the receiving party stop time running for limitation purposes by delaying issuing a claim.

For one reason or another, there is often a considerable delay pursuing claims for payment in a construction context.  This case is a reminder that longstop date for doing so is likely to be six years after the work was done and that inventive arguments based on the Scheme are unlikely to assist.

About this article

Disclaimer
This information is for guidance purposes only and should not be regarded as a substitute for taking legal advice. Please refer to the full General Notices on our website.

About this article

Read, listen and watch our latest insights

art
  • 06 November 2017
  • Employment

Will lawyers save the planet?

Very soon a Norwegian court will hear a case based on environmental concerns against the issue of oil exploration licences. The case is helpfully reported in The Economist (Nov 4-10th).

art
  • 27 October 2017
  • Employment

A much-needed win for vulnerable and exploited domestic workers

As we have previously blogged, UK law does not do enough to protect migrant domestic workers in the UK from abuse, exploitation and modern slavery.

art
  • 27 October 2017
  • Employment

Greek government falls short with discriminatory height requirement for police

The ECJ has held in Ypourgos Ethnikis Pedias kai Thriskevmaton v Kalliri that a minimum height requirement of 170cm imposed by the Greek Government for men and women wishing to join the police force, amounted to indirect sex discrimination and could not be objectively justified.

art
  • 27 October 2017
  • Employment

Government announces start of tribunal fees refund scheme

Following the Supreme Court’s ruling this summer that Employment Tribunal fees were unlawful, the government has announced its fees refund scheme: individuals will be refunded their original fee along with an interest of 0.5% calculated from the date of the original payment up until the refund date.

art
  • 13 October 2017
  • Employment

Mental Health Week 2017: tackling the stigma of mental health in the workplace

The 10th October marked World Mental Health Day and this year’s theme was ‘mental health in the workplace’.

art
  • 13 October 2017
  • Employment

Postal staff threaten strike action over Pensions

Since March 2017, under the Trade Union Act, strikes require a turnout of at least 50% of all eligible voters. In the first large scale vote since the legislation came into force, postal workers represented by the Communications Workers Union (CWU) have voted to strike with a turnout of 73.7% easily passing this 50% threshold. Of those who voted an overwhelming 89% backed the strike.